Supporters of Felicia H. Simmons-Stovall's 2nd Subcircuit judicial bid have launched a campaign website. That's a link to the site in the preceding sentence; a link has been also added to the blog Sidebar.

Simmons-Stovall has been licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 1996, according to ARDC. Her campaign bio says that she currently works for the Illinois Secretary of State Securities Department, representing that office "in actions against unscrupulous individuals who prey upon the elderly and unsuspecting investors and commit financial fraud related to investments, loan brokering, business opportunities and business brokering."

According to her campaign bio, Simmons-Stovall has done pro bono work for the Legal Assistance Foundation of Chicago and Chicago Christian Industrial League. It also stresses her involvement with the Apostolic Church of God. A member of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority, Incorporated, Simmons-Stovall is married and is the mother of three adult children.

In addition to Simmons-Stovall, Judge Sondra Nicole Denmark and Chelsey R. Robinson are also seeing the "A" vacancy in the 2nd Subcircuit. (The links in the preceding sentence are to the campaign websites of these other candidates.)

The New Covenant Missionary Baptist Church, 754 E. 77th Street, will host the event. The service will start at 9:00 a.m., but IJC members are asked to arrive (with their robes) at 8:30 a.m.

Supporters of Associate Judge Mary Catherine Marubio's bid for the O'Brien vacancy in the 10th Subcircuit have launched a campaign website and scheduled a fundraiser for their candidate on Wednesday, February 19, from 5:00 to 7:00 p.m. at the Plymouth Restaurant and Rooftop Bar. That's a link to the campaign website in the preceding sentence; a link has also been added to the blog Sidebar.

Tickets for next week's event, which is billed as an LGBTQ and Ally Fundraiser, are $75 apiece. Sponsorships are available (Supporter - $100, Benefactor - $150, Patron - $500, Sponsor - $1,000, Justice for All Champion - $2500). "Young Professionals" will be admitted for $50 each. For more information, including what the organizers consider to be a "young professional," email judgemarubio@gmail.com. Tickets are also available at this page on the candidate's campaign website.

The Host Committee for this event includes 44th Ward Ald. Tom Tunney, State Sen. Sara Feigenholtz (6th Dist.), State Rep. Kelly Cassidy (14th Dist.), Deputy Ald. Bennett Lawson, Brent Adams, Sam Adam Jr., Megan Carney, Dion Contreras, Jay Paul Deratany, Jon Erickson, Jeffrey Knipmeyer, Franco La Marca, Owen Daniel McCarter, Gail Morse, Michael Oppenheimer, Coco Soodek, Bonn Wade, and Jay Rowell.

Marubio became an Associate Judge in 2016. She currently serves as President of the Alliance of Illinois Judges. Before joining the bench, Marubio worked as an Administrative Law Judge for Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation and, after May 2014, as the agency's Ethics Officer. She has been licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 1997. Before joining IDFPR, Marubio had her own law practice, serving, among other things, as General Counsel for the Columbian Consulate in 12 Midwestern states.

Marubio is one of five candidates for the O'Brien vacancy. The other candidates are John Hourihane, Audrey Victoria Cosgrove, Liam Kelly, and Associate Judge Daniel Alexander Trevino.

Supporters of Judge Celestia L. Mays' countywide judicial bid are planning a fundraiser on Wednesday, February 19, from 5:00 to 7:00 p.m., at Petterino's, 150 N. Dearborn. Tickets for the event are $100 each, but sponsorships are available ($250 - Bronze, $500 - Silver, $1,000 - Gold, $1,500 - Platinum, or $2,500 - Diamond).

Tickets are available at this page on the candidate's campaign website. For more information about the event, email info@judgecelestiamays.com.

The campaign is asking interested persons to RSVP as soon as possible.

Mays is a candidate for the countywide Funderburk vacancy, a vacancy to which she was appointed by the Illinois Supreme Court. After being slated for that vacancy by the Cook County Democratic Party, Mays accepted appointment as an associate judge.

There are three other candidates for that vacancy, Jacqueline Marie Griffin, Daniel L. Collins, and Mary Therese Quinn.

The reference in the title of this post, dear Millennial readers, is to a song by Shirley Ellis, from 1964. It is a known earworm.

The Appellate Court ordered the removal of countywide judicial candidate Caroline Patricia Jamieson from the March primary ballot last Thursday.

The case is Oberholtzer v. Cook County Officers Electoral Board, 2020 IL App (1st) 200218-U.

The Court's February 13 decision affirmed a January 30 Circuit Court order.

The Circuit Court's order overturned the January 6 decision of the Cook County Officers Electoral Board, which had overruled the objection to Jamieson's candidacy. (Election law cases move with astounding speed because elections can not be held up by disputes over who should appear on the ballot.)

The case involves the interpretation of §7-10.2 of the Illinois Election Code, 10 ILCS 5/7-10.2.

To understand the objection, one must first recall Patrick Michael O'Brien.

In or about 2005 a Park Ridge attorney named Frederick Rhine decided he wanted to run for judge. He observed that persons with certain Irish names (like O'Brien, not like Leyhane) did extraordinarily well in judicial elections, while persons saddled with other monikers, even proud German names like Rhine, fared less well.

This may be Captain Obvious stuff today; it was perhaps less well known in 2005. But the originality of this insight is beside the point; the point is the action Mr. Rhine took after achieving this epiphany: Mr. Rhine legally changed his name to Patrick Michael O'Brien.

The Sun-Times got wind of the name change that Fall, and ran a story about it.

Then it ran another one in January 2006 when Mr. O'Brien chose not to file for the 2006 primary, thereby avoiding the ambush set for him by the newspaper. (Mr. O'Brien has long since returned to being Mr. Rhine.)

While the immediate crisis was averted, the Powers That Be were unwilling to take the chance that someone else -- someone not vetted by and indebted to the Powers The Be -- might try something similar. Citizen initiative is all well and good... as long as it is strictly controlled.

Then State Rep. (later Cook County Commissioner) John A. Fritchey was the original sponsor of HB 4173 in the 94th General Assembly -- in November 2005 -- but the bill gained bipartisan support in January 2006 when Rep. Jim Durkin, now the Republican House leader, but then a freshman representative serving by mid-term appointment, signed on as a co-sponsor. State Sen. Don Harmon, now the Senate President, was the bill's chief sponsor in the Senate.

Among other things, HB 4173 amended §7-10.2 as follows:

Sec. 7-10.2. In the designation of the name of a candidate on a petition for nomination or certificate of nomination the candidate's given name or names, initial or initials, a nickname by which the candidate is commonly known, or a combination thereof, may be used in addition to the candidate's surname. If a candidate has changed his or her name, whether by a statutory or common law procedure in Illinois or any other jurisdiction, within 3 years before the last day for filing the petition or certificate for that office, whichever is applicable, then (i) the candidate's name on the petition or certificate must be followed by "formerly known as (list all prior names during the 3-year period) until name changed on (list date of each such name change)" and (ii) the petition or certificate must be accompanied by the candidate's affidavit stating the candidate's previous names during the period specified in (i) and the date or dates each of those names was changed; failure to meet these requirements shall be grounds for denying certification of the candidate's name for the ballot or removing the candidate's name from the ballot, as appropriate, but these requirements do not apply to name changes resulting from adoption to assume an adoptive parent's or parents' surname, marriage to assume a spouse's surname, or dissolution of marriage or declaration of invalidity of marriage to assume a former surname. No other designation such as a political slogan, as defined by Section 7-17, title or degree, or nickname suggesting or implying possession of a title, degree or professional status, or similar information may be used in connection with the candidate's surname , except that the title "Mrs." may be used in the case of a married woman.

Now we come to the current case.

Caroline Jamieson Golden challenged Judge David Navarro for a 4th Subcircuit vacancy in the 2018 primary. She lost.

In 2018, Caroline P. Golden was appointed to an unexpired term on the Lyons Township Trustees of Schools.

According to ARDC, Caroline P. Golden is listed on the Master Roll of Attorneys. ARDC also notes her full former name as Caroline Patricia Jamieson.

She is registered to vote as Caroline Golden.

And on November 25, 2019 Caroline Patricia Jamieson filed for the countywide C. Sheehan vacancy.

All the same person.

On December 9 Karla Katz Oberholtzer filed an Objection to Jamieson's nominating petitions.

The operative provisions of her papers are as follows:

   5.   Pursuant to 10 ILCS 5/7-10.2, if the candidate has changed his or her name within three years before the last day for the filing of petitions for public office, those petitions, and her statement of candidacy, must contain a designation as "formerly known as" listing all prior names during the three year time period until the name changed, and listing the date of the name change.

   6.   Further the petition must be accompanied by a candidate's affidavit stating the candidate's previous names during the period specified and the date or dates of each of the name changes.

   7.   Failure to meet these requirements is grounds for denying certification of the candidate's name for the ballot or removing the candidates name from the ballot as appropriate. This candidate within the last three years has ran for public office using the name CAROLINE JAMIESON GOLDEN, and, by appointment, held public office under the name CAROLINE P. GOLDEN. The candidate has now changed her name to run for this public office as CAROLINE PATRICIA JAMIESON.

   8.   The candidate has failed to follow the provisions of 10 ILCS 5/7-10.2 and her name must be stricken from the ballot.

In plain English, the Objector was accusing Jamieson of doing what Mr. Rhine had thought about doing 15 years ago.

The obvious differences between these two situations were duly noted by the Election Board's assigned hearing officer (Report and Recommended Decision, p. 3, footnotes omitted):

§7-10.2 of the Election Code does set forth requirements for those who acquire new names within three years of filing nominating petitions, but it expressly permits candidates to use their given names. It also exempts name changes resulting from adoption, marriage, divorce or annulment. As the candidate now before the Board states, the name she used on her nominating papers is her given name and not a new name acquired outside of the ordinary name changes that occur in life. Objector's contention that because Candidate had previously run for office using her spouse's surname, she is now somehow precluded from using her birth name, is simply not supported by the statute or this Board's prior decisions. In fact, in the absence of relevant case law ruling otherwise, should the County Officers Electoral Board now adopt Objector's prayer, the Candidate could be entitled to assert that the Board had deviated from past practice, in violation of Briscoe v. Kusper, 435 F.2d 1046 (7th Cir. 1971).

In the absence of judicial precedent, the hearing officer's principal reliance for her conclusion was on an Electoral Board decision from the last election cycle, Harris v. Orr, 17 COEB JUD 18 (Dec. 2018).

There are some factual distinctions between Harris and the current one. The challenged candidate, Erika Orr, was married a shorter time than Jamieson. She did change her voter registration to reflect her married name, but she did not change her name on the Master Roll of Illinois Attorneys maintained by ARDC. (After the Electoral Board overruled the challenge to her petitions, Orr went on to win election to a 1st Subcircuit seat.)

In adopting the hearing officer's recommendation in the Harris case, the Cook County Officers Electoral Board stated (Decision, p. 2):

In our opinion, the purpose of the statute in question is to force Candidates who have recently acquired new names in processes outside of the "ordinary" name changes that occur in life, to divulge those former names. The Candidate herein does not fit into that class of Candidates.

In reversing the Electoral Board's decision, the Circuit Court noted the numerous instances in which Jamieson had used her married name, Golden, "for close to 20 years," finding also (¶14):

The Candidate did not obtain a legal change of name, did not obtain a dissolution of marriage or a judgment of dissolution with leave to allow the Candidate to resume the use of her former name, Caroline Patricia Jamieson.

The Circuit Court concluded (emphasis mine) that "the Candidate's nominating petitions are in violation of 10 ILCS 5/7-10.2 in that the Candidate['s] legal given and surname is Caroline Patricia Golden and remained so on November 25, 2019, when the nomination petitions were filed with the Board of Elections, and was not legally changed to Jamieson at any time prior to November 25, 2019."

So the objection was that Jamieson had changed her name without providing a "formerly known as" disclosure and affidavit, in contravention of §7-10.2; the Electoral Board disagreed. The trial court essentially agreed with the Electoral Board on this point, finding instead that the fatal defect was that the candidate had failed to change her name back from Golden to Jamieson.

The Appellate Court majority decision affirming the Circuit Court's order removing Jamieson from the ballot, written by Justice Eileen O'Neill Burke, agreed with both the Electoral Board and the Circuit Court. Noting that the "Candidate and the Electoral Board were chiefly concerned with the second provision of the statute, the 'Name Change' provision," the Appellate Court majority stated, "The Candidate maintains that she has not changed her name by any 'statutory or common law procedure' within the last three years and, thus, this section does not invalidate her nomination papers. We agree. There is no suggestion in the record that the Candidate has changed her name by any statutory or common law procedure in Illinois or any other jurisdiction within the last three years requiring her to list any former names on her nomination papers." 2020 IL App (1st) 200218-U, ¶24.

However, because of all the many and various ways in which the Candidate used her married name, Golden, in preference to the name she'd been born with, Jamieson, her "surname" for purposes of the first section of §7-10.2 was Golden. 2020 IL App (1st) 200218-U, ¶¶25-27. The majority concluded, "There has been no information presented to this court showing that she has used the surname Jamieson in any legal capacity in over a decade. Consequently, under the language of section 7-10.2 of the Election Code, the Candidate was required to list her given name as 'Caroline Patricia' and her surname as 'Golden.' The Candidate’s failure to do so violated the terms of section 7-10.2 of the Election Code," 2020 IL App (1st) 200218-U, ¶28.

A dissent by Justice Bertina Lampkin agreed that the "name change" provisions of the statute had not been triggered, adding (2020 IL App (1st) 200218-U, ¶36):

[I]n conformance with section 7-10.2, Jamieson was not required to use the “formerly known as” designation on her petition and submit an affidavit attesting to the dates of a name change within the designated three-year time period because those “requirements do not apply to name changes resulting from *** marriage to assume a spouse’s surname.” See id. Under the plain terms of section 7-10.2, Jamieson’s use in her personal and professional life of her surname acquired by marriage, Golden, instead of her surname bestowed at birth, Jamieson, falls under the statutory exception of a name change resulting from marriage to assume a spouse’s surname.

Now, here's the part I don't understand.

As noted, the original Objections to Jamieson's petitions did not raise the "surname" issue, only the "name change."

And in her petition for review in the Circuit Court, the Objector persisted in her argument that the "Candidate changed her surname from 'Golden' to 'Jamieson,'" and therefore, she was subject to the "formerly known as" portion of the statute. But she also contended "that the Board’s interpretation of section 7-10.2 of the Election Code was 'legally faulty.' The Objector argued that, under the statute, the terms 'given name' and 'surname' have different meanings." 2020 IL App (1st) 200218-U, ¶12.

To my untrained, non-election law specialist's eye, that seems like a change in the Objector's position from that which was asserted in her original Objections.

And I don't see anything in the Objections, or in the Election Board's Decision, or in the Hearing Officer's Report and Recommended Decision (these being the documents I reviewed for this post) in which the "surname" issue is raised.

The Hearing Officer's Report and Recommended Decision does note, at pp. 3-4,

[I]n her Response to Candidate's Motion to Strike, Objector wanders far afield of her initial petition and alleges that Candidate does not have a right to ballot access because she engaged in fraudulent or deceptive activity by using her maiden name. As Objector did not raise these matters in her initial petition, they will not be considered. The law is clear that Objector may not amend her petition (See Cook County Officers Electoral Board Rules of Procedure, Rule 9; Weber v. Winnebago County Officers Electoral Board, 966 N.E.2d 462, 467 (2nd Dist., 2012). The only matter Objector raised in her petition (and the only matter of which Candidate received notice) is whether she was required to adhere to the name change provisions set out in §7-10.2.

If this is a correct statement of the applicable law, then I wonder how the Circuit Court and Appellate Court were able to consider a different issue than the one raised by the Objector's original papers and resolve it adversely to Jamieson.

Of course, in other areas of the law, parties are sometimes subject to limitations that do not apply to the courts. That may be the case here... but it wasn't stated. If that were really the rule here, it would seem rather harsh as applied, given the very tight timelines in election law cases.

The other thing that occurred to me, as a non-election law specialist, is that neither the Electoral Board, nor the Circuit Court, nor the Appellate Court had any case law interpreting §7-10.2 to work with. And yet, at least so far, the Appellate Court's Oberholtzer decision has been filed as a Rule 23 Order, meaning it is non-precedential and may not be cited in other cases.

This is not the place to address the shortcomings of Illinois Supreme Court Rule 23, at least as applied.

But it seems to me that the Oberholtzer case, whether precedential or not, must be seen as a 'shot across the bow' for many candidates, if not for this election cycle (since objections are closed), then for the future.

Two things seem certain to me.

First, Jamieson was not alone in trying to pick the most favorable name from those seemingly available. In this election cycle, an attorney listed on the Master Roll as Suzanne Alt is running for the countywide Larsen vacancy as Suzanne Therese McEneely, a name by which she was formerly known, according to ARDC. And 7th Subcircuit candidate Marcia O'Brien Conway was listed on the master roll as Marcia Organ when I first wrote about her campaign, last September (her ARDC listing has since been updated). I'm sure there are other examples; these were the ones that came to mind as I prepared this.

Second, if I thought I could use the name Jamieson for a St. Patrick's Day Primary, I sure as heck would try. I would prefer to use Bushmill Guinness Jamieson if I could (and, yes, I know the stimulating beverage is spelled Jameson, not Jamieson -- let's not quibble). I don't blame the candidate for trying; I am surprised the gambit failed.

Supporters of Judge Sharon O. Johnson's bid for the Simon vacancy on the Appellate Court have announced two upcoming events.

First up, on Saturday, February 22, from 6:00 to 10:00 p.m., is a reception for "all Lindbloom Eagles" to support their fellow alum at Geno's Place, 12401 S. Ashland Ave., Calumet Park. Organizers say a minimum contribution of $20 will be appreciated.

Next, on Saturday, February 29, the Johnson campaign is hosting an Early Voting Kickoff Party, from 6:00 to 9:00 p.m., at Chuck's Haven Banquet Hall, 14844 Chicago Road, Dolton. Admission is free, but good will offerings will be accepted.

Today is the last day to purchase advance tickets to next week's Advocates Society Annual Installation Dinner.

The Dinner is set for Monday, February 24, at the Kimpton Allegro Hotel, 171 West Randolph Street. Cocktails start at 5:00 p.m. Dinner and the program follow, starting at 6:00 p.m.

Congressman Mike Quigley will receive the 2020 Advocates Award of Merit at the event. Jonathan Clark Green will be installed as the Advocates new President. Other officers to be installed include First Vice President, Audrey Cosgrove; Second Vice President, Allison R. Pawlicki; Third Vice President, Christina Malecki; Secretary, Joanna Pawlowska; Treasurer, Ann Melichar; and Historian, Erik Wachnik.

If purchased today, tables of 10 may be had for $1,350. Individual advance tickets are $150 each. Tickets may be obtained at this page on the Advocates website. If available, tickets can be purchased at the door for $175 each.

Some sponsorship opportunities may also be available for those who act today. Email Jonathan Clark Green at jcgreenlaw98@gmail.com.

A campaign website has been launched in support of Joe Gump's 13th Subcircuit Democratic Primary bid. That's a link to the campaign website in the preceding sentence; a link has also been added to the blog Sidebar.

Licensed as an attorney in Illinois since 1987, according to ARDC, Gump was a career public defender (based in Rolling Meadows for the better part of two decades) who recently moved into private practice. His website notes that Gump has served as an Executive Board member of AFSCME Council 31, Local 3315 (the "Cook County Public Defender Association") for 28 years.

Gump is married and has three daughters, the youngest of whom is a senior at Fremd High School. Long-time Palatine residents, the Gump family moved to Inverness four years ago. In addition to serving as an Assistant Public Defender, Gump and his wife have operated a business, College Nannies, Sitters & Tutors, in the 13th Subcircuit since 2016.

A 1978 graduate of Notre Dame High School (now Notre Dame College Prep), Gump was a candidate for a 13th Subcircuit vacancy in 2008. He also sought a countywide vacancy in 1996. He was elected a delegate to the Democratic National Convention in 2012.

Five slated countywide judicial candidates and two subcircuit candidates, all of them currently serving judges, are scheduled to appear at a judicial forum on Sunday, March 1, from 1:30 to 3:30 p.m., at Christ Bible Church, 7877 S. Coles.

Pastor Monte Rollerson of the South Side Gospel Church is the host for this event. Admission is free.

I do not know if other candidates have been invited to this event, or if other candidates would be welcome. I have emailed Pastor Ford about this and I will update this post if I receive additional information.

FWIW will report endorsements in Cook County judicial races -- when these can be verified.

But there's a catch: I won't report that the Butchers, Bakers and Candlestick Makers' Union has endorsed Candidate Smith unless I can find out who else, if anyone, that said organization has endorsed from among the ranks of judicial candidates. Candidate Smith is always thrilled to receive that coveted endorsement, and often shares the happy news with yours truly -- but Candidate Smith generally doesn't know who else has received the nod from the BBCM. And, though I inquire, the BBCM typically does not respond.

So far, in this election season, I've reported the endorsements made by the Chicago Federation of Labor -- and that's about it.

I've got documentation from a few more groups and posts about these endorsements will be rolled out in due course.

But... seriously... why would a group that goes to the trouble to make an endorsement in a contested judicial primary not want to publicize it? Presumably an organization endorses someone because it believes that the candidate would, if elected, be friendly or helpful in some way to the endorsing organization. So why not tell the world that this candidate is worthy of support?

I suppose that one answer to that question should be obvious, even to a naif like myself: If the Butchers, Bakers and Candlestick Makers like someone, there will be those who automatically refuse to support that someone because of that support.

Case in point: I just got hold of the endorsements made for the upcoming primary by the Fraternal Order of Police, Chicago Lodge No. 7. Some readers will be interested in, though perhaps not swayed by, the FOP's guidance in these matters. But there will also be some FWIW readers who are so reflexively anti-police that they will vote against any candidate supported by the FOP.

That cuts both ways, of course. In the last election cycle, a 10th Subcircuit candidate advertised the support of both then-45th Ward Ald. John Arena and the FOP -- at a time when Arena was making complaints to Chicago's Civilian Office of Police Accountabilty (COPA) about social media posts made by police officers and firefighters. Second City Cop, the resolutely unofficial police blog, pitched a fit about it -- and things got a little high schoolish -- there was a question of who dumped who first -- but the upshot was that the candidate was scrubbed from Arena's palm cards. I wrote about it at the time. (The candidate went on to win anyway.)

The point I tried to make then -- and will try to make again here -- is that any successful political campaign requires the construction of a winning coalition.

In the law, coalitions might be considered analogous to joint ventures, not partnerships: temporary alliances for a limited, specific purpose. The components of the judicial candidate's coalition need agree only that Smith or Jones would make a fine judge; they need never again agree on anything else. Coalitions may become permanent alliances, but the judicial candidate can not worry about that: If the coalition coalesces, just once, on Primary Day, it will have served the judicial candidate's purpose.

Building a successful coalition is almost certainly harder for a judicial candidate than for other types of political candidates: A judicial candidate can not promise to do anything for anyone. Supreme Court Rule 67A.(3)(d)(i) expressly prohibits a judicial candidate from making "statements that commit or appear to commit the candidate with respect to cases, controversies or issues within cases that are likely to come before the court." What a judicial candidate can do is to cultivate a reputation for fairness and integrity so as to earn the trust and support of persons who would not otherwise agree on the color of the sky.

And then I wake up....

The Chicago Bar Association released its ratings of judicial candidates today.

The CBA found three of the seven Supreme Court candidates "Highly Qualified," and three others "Qualified." One candidate was rated "Not Recommended" by the group.

All candidates had to fill out an extensive questionnaire in order to be evaluated by the CBA. Sitting judges are required to list personal, professional and judicial references and to provide the names of lawyers who have recently appeared before him or her. Candidates with fewer than four years on the bench are also asked to identify adversaries with whom they worked before taking the bench. Lawyer candidates are asked to provide detailed information about their jury and non-jury trial experiences, the names of five judges before whom they have appeared and a list of at least 20 lawyers who have represented adverse positions in matters handled by them.

Health concerns are disclosed and examined; media mentions are scrutinized. Candidates must agree to release of disciplinary records.

A two-person investigation team vets the persons identified in the candidates' questionnaires and prepares a report which serves as the basis of an interview with members of the evaluating committee.

The CBA says that candidates who submit a questionnaire and participate in the screening process are evaluated on the basis of seven criteria: integrity, legal knowledge, legal ability, professional experience, judicial temperament, diligence and punctuality.

After the candidate is interviewed, the committee members vote. A candidate must receive a 60 percent favorable vote of the hearing panel members to receive a “Qualified” finding and an 80 percent favorable vote to receive a “Highly Qualified” finding. Candidates who receive less than a 60 percent favorable vote receive a “Not Recommended” finding, as do candidates who decline to participate in the evaluation process.

Without further adieu, here are the CBA evaluations of the seven Supreme Court candidates:

JESSE G. REYES -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Justice Jesse G. Reyes is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Justice Reyes was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1984 and served as a Cook County Associate Judge from 1997-2008; Circuit Court of Cook County Judge from 2008-2012; and as a Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court from 2012-present. Justice Reyes is well regarded for his diligence, judicial experience, and passionate commitment to the law and our justice system.

P. SCOTT NEVILLE, JR. -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Justice P. Scott Neville is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Justice Neville was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1974 and was engaged in private practice for 25 years before his appointment to the Circuit Court of Cook County in 1999. In 2004, Judge Neville was appointed to the Illinois Appellate Court where he served until his appointment to the Illinois Supreme Court in 2018. Justice Neville has extensive appellate experience and is well regarded for his deep understanding and knowledge of the law. Justice Neville is committed to improving the Illinois Courts and possesses all the requisite qualifications for service on the Illinois Supreme Court.

SHELLY A. HARRIS -- QUALIFIED

Justice Sheldon A. Harris is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Justice Harris was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1966 and served as a Cook County Circuit Court Judge from 2000-2010. Justice Harris was appointed to the Illinois Appellate Court in 2010 and elected to the Appellate Court in 2014. Justice Harris has extensive appellate court experience and is well regarded for his legal knowledge, legal ability, diligence in preparing for oral arguments and issuing timely opinions, and good judicial demeanor.

CYNTHIA Y. COBBS -- QUALIFIED

Justice Cynthia Cobbs is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Justice Cobbs was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and has served as a judicial law clerk to an Illinois Appellate Court Illinois and Illinois Supreme Court Justice from 1989-1997. Justice Cobbs served as counsel in the Administrative Office of the Illinois Courts (AOIC) from 1997-1999 and as Chief AOIC Legal Counsel from 1999-2002. Justice Cobbs served as Director of the Administrative Office of the Illinois Courts from 2002-2011. Justice Cobbs was appointed to the Circuit Court of Cook County in 2011 and elected to the Circuit Court in 2014. As a Circuit Court Judge, Justice Cobbs presided over civil jury trials, small claims, forcible entry, and traffic court cases in the First Municipal District. Justice Cobbs was assigned to the Illinois Appellate Court in 2015. Justice Cobbs has extensive knowledge about the administration and operation of the court system and possesses the legal knowledge, legal ability, demeanor, and experience to serve as a Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court.

MARGARET STANTON McBRIDE -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Justice Margaret Stanton McBride is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Justice McBride was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1976 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 10 years. Justice McBride was appointed an Associate Cook County Judge in 1987 and was elected to the Circuit Court of Cook County in 1990. Justice McBride was elected to the Illinois Appellate Court in 1998. Justice McBride has a distinguished track record as an appellate court justice and is highly regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, integrity, excellent demeanor, and work ethic.

DANIEL EPSTEIN -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Daniel Epstein is “Not Recommended” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Mr. Epstein was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2015 and worked for a prominent Chicago law firm for approximately four years. Prior to his admission to the Illinois Bar, Mr. Epstein served as a research assistant for one year at the University of Chicago Law School and as a Judicial Extern for one year in the U.S. District Court. At the present time, Mr. Epstein is actively campaigning for the Illinois Supreme Court. Mr. Epstein has had limited practice experience and, at this stage in his legal career, he does not possess the depth and breadth of experience to serve as a Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court.

NATHANIEL ROOSEVELT HOWSE -- QUALIFIED

Judge Nathaniel Howse is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court. Justice Howse was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1976 and was elected to serve as a Circuit Court Judge in 1998. Judge Howse served as a Cook County Circuit Court Judge until his appointment to the Illinois Appellate Court in 2009. In 2012, Justice Howse was elected to the Illinois Appellate Court. Justice Howse has extensive appellate court experience and is well regarded for his knowledge of the law and diligence in issuing opinions in a timely manner.

The Chicago Bar Association today released its evaluations of candidates for judicial positions in the upcoming primary. The CBA's process and criteria are explained in this post. The CBA's complete findings and explanations of those findings may be found by following this link.

The CBA Judicial Evaluation Committee found three Appellate Court candidates "Highly Qualified." Two more were found "Qualified," while one was found "Not Recommended."

Here are the CBA's findings for Appellate Court candidates:


MAUREEN PATRICIA O’LEARY -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Maureen Patricia O’Leary is “Not Recommended” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Ms. O’Leary was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2002 and is currently serving as Vice President of Claims and Litigation for Aperion Care. Ms. O’Leary was a sole practitioner from 2004-2008 concentrating in personal injury, real estate, and child support matters. At this stage of her career, Ms. O’Leary does not possess the requisite depth and breadth of practice experience to effectively serve as a Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court.

CAROLYN J. GALLAGHER -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Judge Carolyn Gallagher is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Judge Gallagher was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1982 and was elected to the Circuit Court of Cook County in 2016. Judge Gallagher is currently assigned to the Probate Division. Judge Gallagher clerked for an Appellate Court Justice from 1982-1985 and during her legal career she had extensive trial and appellate practice experience. Judge Gallagher is highly regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, and strong credentials in legal research and legal writing.

SANDRA GISELA RAMOS -- QUALIFIED

Judge Sandra Ramos is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Judge Ramos was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1986 and was elected to the Circuit Court in 2010. Judge Ramos is currently assigned to the Law Division. Judge Ramos is an experienced trial judge and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, diligence, work ethic, and fine demeanor.

MICHAEL B. HYMAN -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Justice Michael B. Hyman is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Justice Hyman was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1977. Justice Hyman is highly regarded for his knowledge of the law, integrity, legal experience, work ethic, and excellent writing skills. Justice Hyman teaches other jurists and is dedicated to improving the justice system.


JOHN GRIFFIN -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Justice John C. Griffin is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Justice Griffin was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1976 and was appointed to the Circuit Court of Cook County in 2008. Justice Griffin was elected to the Circuit Court in 2010 and served as a supervising judge in the Law Division before his appointment to the Illinois Appellate Court in 2018. Justice Griffin is hardworking and well regarded for his knowledge of the law, broad experience, and excellent legal ability.

SHARON O. JOHNSON -- QUALIFIED

Judge Sharon O. Johnson is “Qualified” for the office of Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court. Judge Johnson was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1996 and was elected to the Circuit Court in 2010. Judge Johnson is currently assigned to the Domestic Relations Division in the Sixth Municipal District and presides over cases involving dissolution of marriage, parentage, and allocation of parental responsibility. Judge Johnson is an experienced jurist well regarded for her work ethic, diligence, calm demeanor, and legal knowledge.

The Chicago Bar Association today released its evaluations of candidates for judicial positions in the upcoming primary. The CBA's process and criteria are explained in this post. The CBA's complete findings and explanations of those findings may be found by following this link.

The CBA says that 104 candidates are seeking Circuit Court positions. Of these, 91 were screened by the CBA. The 13 candidates who did not submit to screening were automatically found "Not Recommended" according to CBA JEC governing bylaws. Ten of the 91 who were screened were also found "Not Recommended."

On the other hand, the CBA Judicial Evaluation Committee found 13 Circuit Court candidates "Highly Qualified" and 68 other candidates "Qualified."

This post will look only at the CBA's ratings in countywide races.


TIESHA L. SMITH -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Tiesha L. Smith declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

CRISTIN KEELY McDONALD DUFFY -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Cristin McDonald Duffy is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Duffy was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1996 and has served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for approximately 22 years. Ms. Duffy has extensive criminal felony trial experience and is now Deputy Supervisor in charge of the State’s Attorney’s Real Estate Tax Unit. Ms. Duffy is also responsible for the State’s Attorney’s training and mentoring program in the Civil Division. Ms. Duffy is highly regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal experience, excellent temperament, and managerial skills.

KERRIE MALONEY LATYIN -- QUALIFIED

Judge Kerrie Maloney Laytin is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Laytin was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2000 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2019. Prior to her appointment to the bench, Judge Laytin served from 2002-2019 in the Appeals Division, City of Chicago’s Law Department. Judge Laytin has extensive appellate court experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, diligence, and thoughtful and deliberate demeanor.


KELLY MARIE McCARTHY -- QUALIFIED

Kelly Marie McCarthy is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. McCarthy was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2001 and has served the majority of her career as a Cook County Assistant Public Defender. Ms. McCarthy is currently serving as Chief of the Indigent Defense-Appeals and Post Convictions Division. Ms. McCarthy has excellent organizational skills and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, integrity and excellent temperament.

AILEEN BHANDARI -- QUALIFIED

Aileen Bhandari is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Bhandari was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2002 and has served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 16 years. Ms. Bhandari is assigned to the Community Justice Center-West. Ms. Bhandari has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for her work ethic, knowledge of the law, legal experience, and excellent temperament.

ELIZABETH “BETH” RYAN -- QUALIFIED

Elizabeth “Beth” Ryan is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Ryan was admitted to practice law in 2004 and is currently a solo practitioner concentrating in personal injury, corporate litigation, and social security disability law. Ms. Ryan is well regarded by her peers and by the judges before whom she has appeared for her knowledge of the law and legal ability.

JAMES T. DERICO, JR. QUALIFIED

Judge James Derico is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Derico was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1985 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2019. Judge Derico is assigned to the First Municipal District and hears a variety of contract and non-jury matters. Judge Derico has extensive legal experience and is well regarded for his legal knowledge, ability, diligence and fine demeanor.


U. O’NEAL -- NOT RECOMMENDED

U. O’Neal declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

LAURA AYALA-GONZALEZ -- QUALIFIED

Laura Ayala-Gonzalez is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Ayala-Gonzalez was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2003 and has served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney her entire career. Ms. Ayala-Gonzalez is currently a supervisor in the Felony Trial Division at the George Leighton Criminal Court Building. Ms. Ayala-Gonzalez is well regarded by her colleagues, judges before whom she has appeared, and by defense lawyers for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, supervisory skills, commitment to public service, and fine demeanor.

JOHN O’MEARA HIGHLY QUALIFIED

John O’Meara is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. O’Meara was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1995 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in medical malpractice, complex litigation, government law, and construction negligence matters. Mr. O’Meara has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, integrity, calm demeanor, and excellent temperament.


JACQUELINE MARIE GRIFFIN -- QUALIFIED

Jacqueline Marie Griffin is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Griffin was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2005 and has served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney her entire career. Ms. Griffin is currently a trial attorney in the Sex Assault and Domestic Violence Unit in the Felony Trial Division. Ms. Griffin has extensive criminal and civil trial experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, fairness, and fine demeanor.

DANIEL L. COLLINS -- QUALIFIED

Danny Collins is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Collins was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1998 and is engaged in private practice concentrating in workers’ compensation, administrative hearings, and appeals. Mr. Collins has an excellent demeanor and possesses the requisite depth and breadth of experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.

MARY THERESE QUINN -- QUALIFIED

Mary Therese Quinn is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Quinn was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and served for 22 years as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney. Since 2011, Ms. Quinn has been engaged in private practice concentrating largely in criminal law matters. Ms. Quinn has extensive criminal trial experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, compassion and excellent demeanor.

CELESTIA L. MAYS -- QUALIFIED

Judge Celestia Mays is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Mays was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1990 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in January 2019. Judge Mays is currently assigned to the Fourth Municipal District and hears a variety of misdemeanor cases and traffic court violations. Judge Mays is hardworking and receives high marks for her fine temperament and people skills.


LEVANDER "VAN" SMITH, JR. -- QUALIFIED

Levander Smith, Jr. is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Smith was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1993 and is currently working in the Office of Legal Services at the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services. Mr. Smith knows the law and has had varied practice experience. He is well regarded for his legal knowledge, work ethic, diligence, and fine temperament.

SUZANNE THERESE McENEELY -- QUALIFIED

Suzanne Therese McEneely is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. McEneely was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2001 and served as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender for 17 years before entering private practice. Ms. McEneely is currently practicing law with an Insurance defense firm. Ms. McEneely has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, excellent demeanor and integrity. Ms. McEneely is also actively involved in community service.

MEGAN KATHLEEN MULAY -- QUALIFIED

Megan Kathleen Mulay is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Mulay was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1999 and has served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney her entire career. Ms. Mulay is assigned to the George Leighton Criminal Court and serves as a First Chair in the Criminal Prosecutions Felony Division. Ms. Mulay has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, diligence, and
excellent demeanor.


ARTHUR D. SUTTON -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Arthur D. Sutton is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Sutton was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1993 and was engaged in private practice until 2010. Mr. Sutton served as a Technical Advisor to the Department of Children and Family Services from 2010-2013 and as Deputy Chief of Parole for the Department of Corrections from 2013-2015. Mr. Sutton is currently in private practice concentrating in a variety of civil and criminal matters. Mr. Sutton has a fine demeanor and is active in his community; however, concerns about his diligence, attention to detail, and depth and breadth of practice experience resulted in a “Not Recommended” finding.

BONNIE CAROL McGRATH -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Bonnie Carol McGrath declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

JENNIFER PATRICIA CALLAHAN -- QUALIFIED

Jennifer Patricia Callahan is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Callahan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2006 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in insurance defense, criminal law, and administrative law matters. Ms. Callahan also serves as an Administrative Law Judge for the Illinois Student Assistance Commission. Prior to entering private practice Ms. Callahan served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 11 years. Ms. Callahan has an excellent temperament and demeanor and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law and legal ability.

CHRIS STACEY -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Christ Stanley Stacey is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Stacey was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1982 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in personal injury law and a broad range of complex corporate and commercial law matters. Mr. Stacey is well spoken and highly regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, and excellent demeanor. Mr. Stacey is also active in a variety of civic and community organizations.

JOY E. TOLBERT NELSON -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Joy E. Tolbert Nelson is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Tolbert Nelson was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2000 and has served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney her entire career. Ms. Tolbert Nelson is currently assigned as first chair to a felony courtroom in the Fourth Municipal District. Ms. Tolbert Nelson is well regarded for her integrity, excellent temperament, and fine people skills. However, concerns about Ms. Tolbert Nelson’s legal knowledge and legal ability along with her lack of civil practice experience resulted in a “Not Recommended” finding.

JOSEPH CHICO -- QUALIFIED

Joseph Chico is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Chico was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1993 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in family law, personal injury, real estate, probate, criminal, and traffic court matters. Since 1996, Mr. Chico has served as an Administrative Law Judge for the City of Chicago. Mr. Chico is an experienced lawyer well regarded for his legal knowledge, legal ability, and excellent demeanor.


TERESA MOLINA -- QUALIFIED

Teresa Molina is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Molina was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2001 and is currently serving as Chief of Real Estate Prosecution at the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation. Ms. Molina has significant trial experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal experience, fine demeanor and temperament.

MICHAEL O’MALLEY -- QUALIFIED

Michael O’Malley is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. O’Malley was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2005 and is currently a Deputy Supervisor in the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office. Mr. O’Malley served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 14½ years and is highly respected by his colleagues for his knowledge of the law, diligence, and fine temperament.


SHEREE DESIREE HENRY -- QUALIFIED

Sheree D. Henry is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Henry was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1994 and served for 18 years as a Cook County Assistant Public Defender and four years with the Public Guardian’s Office. Ms. Henry is well regarded for her integrity, calm demeanor, legal knowledge, and passionate advocacy on behalf of her clients.

DAN WALSH -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Dan Walsh declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

AMANDA “MANDY” PILLSBURY -- QUALIFIED

Amanda Moira Pillsbury is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Pillsbury was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2004 and has served as a Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney since her admission. Ms. Pillsbury is currently assigned to the Felony Trial Division and has extensive jury and bench trial experience. Ms. Pillsbury has a calm demeanor and possesses the legal knowledge and experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.

KEELY PATRICIA HILLISON -- QUALIFIED

Keely Patricia Hillison is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Hillison was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1985 and has concentrated her practice in personal injury and insurance defense matters. Ms. Hillison has trial and appellate experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal experience, diligence, and calm demeanor.


ELIZABETH ANNE WALSH -- QUALIFIED

Elizabeth Anne Walsh is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Walsh was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2006 and concentrates her practice in personal injury and insurance defense matters. Ms. Walsh has had extensive trial experience and possesses the legal knowledge and experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.

LLOYD JAMES BROOKS -- QUALIFIED

Judge Lloyd James Brooks is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Brooks was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2000 and was appointed to the bench in 2018 and is currently assigned to the First Municipal District. Judge Brooks presides over a high volume courtroom and hears a variety of cases involving wage garnishments, citations to discover assets, evictions, and supplementary proceedings. Judge Brooks is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal experience, and excellent demeanor.

HEATHER ANNE KENT -- QUALIFIED

Heather Anne Kent is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Kent was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2006 and has served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for the past 13 years. Ms. Kent is currently assigned to the Felony Trial Division at the George M. Leighton Criminal Court. Ms. Kent has extensive trial experience and is well regarded by defense counsel and the judges before whom she appears for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, and excellent demeanor.


LYNN WEAVER BOYLE -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Lynn Weaver-Boyle “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Weaver-Boyle was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1990 and served as a Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney for nine years. While serving as an Assistant State’s Attorney, Ms. Weaver-Boyle handled felony cases and spent two years in the Gang Unit, which focused exclusively on murder cases. Ms. Weaver-Boyle has spent the last 18 years in private practice concentrating her practice in insurance law, civil Litigation, and subrogation cases. Ms. Weaver-Boyle has extensive jury and non-jury trial experience and is well regarded for her integrity, calm demeanor, knowledge of the law, and legal ability.


LORRAINE MARY MURPHY -- QUALIFIED

Ms. Lorraine Mary Murphy is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Murphy was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2003 and has served her entire career as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney. Ms. Murphy is assigned to the Felony Trial Division at the George Leighton Criminal Court Building. Ms. Murphy has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, fairness and diligence.

JAMES PATRICK CRAWLEY -- QUALIFIED

James Patrick Crawley is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Crawley was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1989 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in complex litigation and insurance defense. Mr. Crawley has extensive practice experience and has been actively engaged in providing pro bono legal services in the community. Mr. Crawley is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal experience, diligence, and fine temperament.

ARACELI REYES DE LA CRUZ -- QUALIFIED

Araceli De La Cruz is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. De La Cruz was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2001 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney from 2001-2009. From 2009-2014, Ms. De La Cruz served as Deputy Chief of Staff, Chicago Transit Authority, Chief Safety and Security Officer with Executive oversight for compliance. From 2014-2016, Ms. De La Cruz served as Chief of General Prosecutions for the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation. Since 2016, Ms. De La Cruz has served as General Counsel and Chief Administrative Officer for Acero Charter Schools. Ms. De La Cruz is hardworking and well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, trial and managerial skills, and excellent temperament.


DEIDRE BAUMANN -- NOT RECOMMENDED*

Deidre Baumann is “Not Recommended” for the office of Associate Judge. Ms. Baumann was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1992 and handles a variety of appellate and civil court matters. Significant concerns were raised about Ms. Baumann’s professionalism, diligence, and organizational skills in managing client matters. Additional concerns about Ms. Baumann’s knowledge of the law and knowledge and adherence to court rules and procedures resulted in her “Not Recommended” finding.

MAURA McMAHON ZELLER -- QUALIFIED

Maura McMahon Zeller is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Zeller was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1993 and serves an Assistant Public Guardian in the Juvenile Court, U.S. District Court, and Domestic Relations Division. Ms Zeller is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in family law with a special focus on child representation and guardian ad litem matters. Ms. Zeller is actively involved in community service and is serving as Board Chair of a community mental health center. Ms. Zeller has an excellent temperament and possesses all the requisite qualifications for service as a Circuit Court Judge.

RUSSELL W. HARTIGAN -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Russell W. Hartigan is “Highly Qualified” for the office of the Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Hartigan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1976 and practiced law from 1977-2010 concentrating in civil trial, workers’ compensation, municipal and appellate practice matters. Mr. Hartigan has handled a number of appeals in both the State and Federal Courts and authored many articles in the ISBA Journal. Mr. Hartigan was appointed to the Circuit Court of Cook County in 2010 and served as a judge until 2017. Mr. Hartigan is currently practicing law with a suburban firm. Mr. Hartigan has extensive experience as a lawyer and as a judge and possesses all the requisite qualifications to serve as Circuit Court Judge.


JILL ROSE QUINN -- QUALIFIED

Jill Rose Quinn is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Quinn was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1983 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in bankruptcy, probate, and real estate law. Ms. Quinn has extensive practice experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, integrity, and outstanding demeanor and temperament.

JAMES SAMUEL WORLEY -- QUALIFIED

James Samuel Worley is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Worley was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2004 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in domestic relations, administrative law, criminal, and DUI defense. Mr. Worley has broad experience in both criminal law and domestic relations. He is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, thoughtful demeanor, and fine temperament.

WENDELIN “WENDI” DeLOACH -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Wendelin “Wendi” DeLoach declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

-------------------------------------------------------
* Pursuant to Section 27.4 of the JEC Resolutions and Procedures, a candidate who has been evaluated and found "NOT RECOMMENDED" for the office of Associate Judge and who shall within three years of such a finding be a candidate for Circuit Judge shall be found "NOT RECOMMENDED" without hearing.

The Chicago Bar Association today released its evaluations of candidates for judicial positions in the upcoming primary. The CBA's process and criteria are explained in this post. The CBA's complete findings and explanations of those findings may be found by following this link.

The CBA says that 104 candidates are seeking Circuit Court positions. Of these, 91 were screened by the CBA. The 13 candidates who did not submit to screening were automatically found "Not Recommended" according to CBA JEC governing bylaws. Ten of the 91 who were screened were also found "Not Recommended."

On the other hand, the CBA Judicial Evaluation Committee found 13 Circuit Court candidates "Highly Qualified" and 68 other candidates "Qualified."

This post will look only at the CBA's ratings of candidates running in the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 6th Subcircuits.



KRISTA D. BUTLER -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Krista D. Butler declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.


TYRIA B. WALTON -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Judge Tyria B. Walton is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Walton was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1997 and served as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender until her appointment to the Circuit Court in 2019. Prior to her appointment to the bench, Judge Walton had extensive criminal trial experience and served on the Public Defender’s Murder Task Force. Judge Walton is currently assigned to Traffic Court and to the Eviction Court. Judge Walton is active in her community and serves as a mentor for children and young adults in the Englewood community. Judge Walton is highly regarded for her knowledge of criminal law, legal ability, calm demeanor, and excellent temperament.



SONDRA NICOLE DENMARK -- QUALIFIED

Sondra N. Denmark is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Denmark was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2004 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 2 ½ years. Since 2008, Ms. Denmark has served as an Assistant State’s Attorney in Will County. Ms. Denmark resides in Cook County and previously served as a part-time hearing officer for the Village of Matteson. Ms. Denmark has trial experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, fine demeanor, and excellent temperament.

FELICIA H. SIMMONS-STOVALL -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Felicia H. Simmons-Stovall is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Simmons-Stovall was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1996 and is currently employed as an enforcement attorney in the Department of Securities, Illinois Secretary of State’s Office. Ms. Simmons-Stovall has extensive administrative law experience but lacks the depth and breadth of practice and court experience to effectively serve as a Circuit Court Judge.

CHELSEY R. ROBINSON -- QUALIFIED

Chelsey R. Robinson is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Robinson was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1996 and is currently in private practice concentrating in criminal and family law. Ms. Robinson has a wide range of practice experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law and diligence.



DANIEL EDWARD MALONEY -- QUALIFIED

Judge Daniel Edward Maloney is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Maloney was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2001 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2019. Prior to his appointment to the bench, Judge Maloney served for 16 years as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney and for two years as Division Counsel to the Drug Enforcement Administration, U.S. Department of Justice. Judge Maloney is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, and calm demeanor.


LAUREN BROUGHAM GLENNON -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Lauren Brougham Glennon is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Glennon was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2003 and has had varied practice experience. Ms. Glennon is currently a solo practitioner and concentrates her practice in commercial litigation and residential real estate matters. Ms. Glennon has an excellent temperament and demeanor; however, at this stage of her career she does not possess the requisite depth and breadth of legal experience to effectively serve as a Circuit Court Judge.

DAVID A. BONOMA QUALIFIED

David A. Bonoma is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Bonoma was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and is a partner in a small Chicago law firm. Mr. Bonoma concentrates his practice in government affairs and land use. Mr. Bonoma represents the Board of Education in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court and has represented a major telecommunications company in several tort cases. Mr. Bonoma has also represented municipalities in reviewing their legal policies and procedures for municipal fines and collection practices. While Mr. Bonoma has limited trial experience, he has had a wide range of legal experience and possesses the requisite legal knowledge and experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.

REGINA ANN MESCALL -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Regina Ann Mescall is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Mescall was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2007 and is currently serving as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney at the George Leighton Criminal Court. Ms. Mescall has extensive experience and has tried many high profile cases. Ms. Mescall is highly regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, work ethic, and excellent demeanor.

JAMES JOHN KNIBBS -- QUALIFIED

James John Knibbs is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Knibbs was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1985 and is currently serving as Of Counsel to a law firm that handles litigation in the state and federal courts. Mr. Knibbs has a wide range of civil and criminal litigation experience. Mr. Knibbs is well regarded for his knowledge of civil and criminal law, legal ability, good demeanor, and fine temperament.

THOMAS J. CONDON, JR. -- QUALIFIED

Thomas J. Condon Jr. is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Condon was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2002 and is currently in private practice concentrating in litigation and government practice. Mr. Condon is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, and integrity.

BRAD S. TELANDER -- QUALIFIED

Brad S. Telander is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Telander was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1983 and is currently a sole practitioner concentrating in criminal defense matters. Mr. Telander has extensive experience and is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, and excellent demeanor.

SCOTT EDWARD LIPINSKI -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Scott Edward Lipinski is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Lipinski was admitted in 2002 and has served as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender since 2003. Mr. Lipinski has criminal practice experience, but concerns about his diligence and temperament resulted in a “Not Recommended” finding.


ERIN HAGGERTY ANTONIETTI -- QUALIFIED\

Judge Erin Haggerty Antonietti is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Antonietti was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1991 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2019. Judge Antonietti has significant experience in both civil and criminal law and is performing well on the bench. Judge Antonietti is well regarded by her fellow judges and by the lawyers who appear in her court.

THOMAS G. O’BRIEN -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Thomas G. O’Brien declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.



JAMIE GUERRA DICKLER -- QUALIFIED

Jamie Guerra Dickler is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Dickler was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2005 and has served as a Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney since her admission to the Bar and is currently assigned to the Felony Trial Division. Ms. Dickler has extensive experience and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, fairness and excellent demeanor.

ANNE SHAW -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Anne Shaw is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Shaw was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1995 and is currently in private practice concentrating in bankruptcy, corporate law, family law, probate, civil rights, commercial litigation, civil litigation, and real estate law. Concerns about the candidate’s diligence, punctuality and temperament resulted in a “Not Recommended” finding.


EILEEN MARIE O’CONNOR -- QUALIFIED

Eileen O’Connor is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. O’Connor was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2006 and concentrates her practice in personal injury law. Ms. O’Connor has had extensive trial and practice experience. Ms. O’Connor is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, work ethic, legal ability, and fine demeanor.

CORI ELI OSHITA -- QUALIFIED

Cory Eli Oshita is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Oshita was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2008 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in domestic relations and family law matters. Mr. Oshita also served as a hearing officer for the Chicago Board of Education. Mr. Oshita is an experienced practitioner well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, work ethic, fine temperament, and calm demeanor.

ANTHONY LUCAFO -- QUALIFIED

Anthony Lucafo is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Lucafo was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2006 and has served as a Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney his entire career. Mr. Lucafo is currently assigned to the Felony Trial Division in the Criminal Court. Mr. Lucafo has extensive trial experience and has taught trial advocacy and juvenile law to law students. Mr. Lucafo is highly regarded for his knowledge of criminal law, trial skills, and excellent temperament.

The Chicago Bar Association today released its evaluations of candidates for judicial positions in the upcoming primary. The CBA's process and criteria are explained in this post. The CBA's complete findings and explanations of those findings may be found by following this link.

The CBA says that 104 candidates are seeking Circuit Court positions. Of these, 91 were screened by the CBA. The 13 candidates who did not submit to screening were automatically found "Not Recommended" according to CBA JEC governing bylaws. Ten of the 91 who were screened were also found "Not Recommended."

On the other hand, the CBA Judicial Evaluation Committee found 13 Circuit Court candidates "Highly Qualified" and 68 other candidates "Qualified."

This post will look only at the CBA's ratings of candidates running in the 7th, 8th, 9th, and 10th Subcircuits.



OWENS “JOE” SHELBY -- QUALIFIED

Owens “Joe” Shelby is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Shelby was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2007 and is currently serving as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney, Second Chair, in the Felony Trial Division in the 4th Municipal District. Mr. Shelby has handled several felony and misdemeanor trials and has had some juvenile and civil experience.

MARCIA O’BRIEN CONWAY -- QUALIFIED

Marcia O’Brien Conway is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Conway was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1984 and served from 1993-2018 as a Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney in the Real Estate Tax Litigation Unit. Ms. Conway has significant trial experience and is well regarded for her diligence and work ethic.

PAMELA REAVES-HARRIS -- QUALIFIED

Pamela Reaves-Harris is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Reaves-Harris was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1992 and has varied practice experience and service as an Administrative Law Judge for the City of Chicago and several suburban municipalities. Ms. Reaves-Harris served as an Illinois State Representative in the General Assembly from 2015-2017. Since 2017, Ms. Reaves-Harris has served as Special Cook County Assistant to Legal Affairs and Legal Counsel for the Bureau of Economic Development, the Department of Building and Zoning, and to the Zoning Board of Appeals. Ms. Reaves-Harris has a fine demeanor and possesses the requisite legal knowledge and experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.

MABLE TAYLOR -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Mable Taylor declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

KRISTIN MARIE LYONS -- QUALIFIED

Kristen Marie Lyons is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Lyons was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2004 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in workers’ compensation, personal injury, and matrimonial matters. Ms. Lyons has extensive litigation experience in both defense and plaintiff cases. Ms. Lyons has a fine temperament and possesses all the requisite qualifications to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.



JONATHAN CLARK GREEN -- QUALIFIED

Jonathan Clark Green is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Green was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1986. Since 2003, Mr. Green has worked as an Assistant Corporation Counsel for the City of Chicago and has handled a wide variety of complex litigation matters involving the Chicago Police Department, federal civil rights cases, and representation of the Civilian Office of Police Accountability. Mr. Green has broad knowledge and experience in both civil and criminal law. Mr. Green is well regarded for his legal knowledge, extensive litigation experience, diligence, and commitment to the law.

BRADLEY R. TROWBRIDGE -- QUALIFIED

Bradley R. Trowbridge is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Trowbridge was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2000 and is engaged in private practice concentrating in family law matters. Mr. Trowbridge has a fine demeanor and temperament and possesses the requisite legal knowledge and experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.


MICHAEL A. FORTI -- QUALIFIED

Michael A. Forti is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Forti was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1980 and has experience in both the private sector and government. Mr. Forti is an experienced lawyer well regarded for his judgment, fine demeanor, and temperament.



PAMELA “PAM” STRATIGAKIS -- QUALIFIED

Pamela “Pam” Stratigakis is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Stratigakis was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2001 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in civil litigation, medical malpractice, healthcare, and the Nursing Home Care Act. Ms. Stratigakis served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney from 2003-2019 and served as First Chair in the Felony Trial Division. Ms. Stratigakis served on the Internet Sex Crimes Against Children Task Force and was engaged in groundbreaking litigation against people involved in Internet sex crimes. Ms. Stratigakis has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for her fine temperament and knowledge of both criminal and civil law.

THOMAS M. CUSHING -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Thomas Cushing is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Cushing was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and was engaged in private practice from 1988-2005 concentrating in civil trial and appellate work. Mr. Cushing worked for the Chicago Climate Exchange from 2006-2010 and as the Managing Director of Public Policy for the Delta Institute, after which he re-entered private practice as of counsel to a small firm. Mr. Cushing has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, diligence, work ethic, and fine temperament.

IRA I. SILVERSTEIN -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Ira I. Silverstein is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Silverstein was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1985 and is currently a sole practitioner engaged in the general practice of law. Mr. Silverstein served as an Illinois State Senator from 1999-2018. In 2017, a complaint involving harassment was filed against Senator Silverstein, which was investigated by the Inspector General who found in 2018 that Senator Silverstein’s conduct was unbecoming of a legislator. This incident and Mr. Silverstein’s limited practice and court experience resulted in a “Not Recommended” finding.

TIMOTHY PATRICK CARTER -- QUALIFIED

Timothy Patrick Carter is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Carter was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1995 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney for 16 years before entering private practice. Mr. Carter is currently engaged in private practice concentrating largely in criminal matters. Mr. Carter has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, diligence and fine demeanor.


THOMAS PETER KOUGIAS -- QUALIFIED

Thomas Peter Kougias is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Kougias was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and is currently serving as an Assistant Winnebago County State’s Attorney. Mr. Kougias served for 21 years as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney and from 2012-2019 he was a sole practitioner concentrating in criminal defense work. Mr. Kougias has extensive criminal trial experience and possesses the legal knowledge and practice experience to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.

JULIE BESS AIMEN -- QUALIFIED

Julie Bess Aimen is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Aimen was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1984 and is a solo practitioner concentrating in criminal defense, family law, civil rights, general litigation, and appellate matters. Ms. Aimen is a seasoned practitioner with extensive trial experience in criminal and domestic relations cases. Ms. Aimen is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, and calm demeanor.

MICHAEL ALAN STROM -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Judge Michael Alan Strom is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Strom was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1977 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2019. Judge Strom is currently assigned to the Circuit Court’s Housing Division. Judge Strom is passionate about his work and possesses all the requisite qualifications for service as a Circuit Court Judge.

BASILEIOS “BILL” FOUTRIS -- QUALIFIED

Basileiois “Bill” Foutris is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Foutris was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2000 and is currently in private practice concentrating in plaintiff’s civil rights and police misconduct litigation. Mr. Foutris has extensive trial experience and has personally tried many high profile cases in the Federal and State Courts. While Mr. Foutris is well regarded for his knowledge of the law and legal experience, there is a need to work on his temperament.



JOHN G. MULROE -- QUALIFIED

John G. Mulroe is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Mulroe was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1988 and served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney until 1994. Since 1995, Mr. Mulroe has been engaged in private practice concentrating in real estate, probate and estate planning, and small business matters. Mr. Mulroe was elected to the Illinois Senate in 2010 where he continues to serve. Mr. Mulroe is a dedicated public servant and is well regarded by his peers for his knowledge of the law, legal experience, integrity, and fine temperament.


JOHN GARRIDO -- NOT RECOMMENDED

John Garrido declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

JON STROMSTA -- QUALIFIED

Jon Stromsta is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Stromsta was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1985 and is currently a partner in the Enterprise Law Group. Mr. Stromsta has a wide range of practice experience in both civil and criminal law. Mr. Stromsta has an excellent temperament and is also active in community service. Mr. Stromsta possesses all the requisite qualifications to serve as a Circuit Court Judge.

MAIRE AILEEN DEMPSEY -- QUALIFIED

Maire Dempsey is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Dempsey was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2002 and is currently a trial partner concentrating in medical malpractice defense. Ms. Dempsey has handled complex legal malpractice cases and is active in community work. Ms. Dempsey is well regarded for her integrity, diligence, knowledge of the law, and excellent demeanor.


DANIEL ALEXANDER TREVINO -- QUALIFIED

Daniel A. Trevino is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Trevino was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1999 and is currently a partner in a leading defense firm. Mr. Trevino is well regarded for his legal knowledge and experience in complex litigation cases. Mr. Trevino knows the law and is qualified for service as a Circuit Court Judge.

JOHN HOURIHANE -- QUALIFIED

John N. Hourihane, Jr. is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Hourihane was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1998 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in commercial litigation, appellate practice, probate and real estate matters. Mr. Hourihane has extensive experience in commercial litigation and appellate practice and has handled a number of complex legal matters. Mr. Hourihane is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal experience, fine demeanor and temperament.

AUDREY VICTORIA COSGROVE -- QUALIFIED

Audrey Victoria Cosgrove is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Cosgrove was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1990 and has served as a Cook County Assistant Public Defender and in private practice. Ms. Cosgrove is currently serving as Deputy Chief Legal Counsel for the Illinois Department of Labor. Ms. Cosgrove is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, diverse practice experience, and fine demeanor.

MARY CATHERINE MARUBIO -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Judge Mary Catherine Marubio is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Marubio was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1997 and concentrated her practice in state and federal criminal defense work. Judge Marubio also represented the Columbia Consulate in Chicago. Judge Marubio is currently assigned to the Pretrial Division of the George Leighton Criminal Court, where she hears a variety of matters including: preliminary hearings for felony traffic including DUI cases, out-of-state fugitive warrants and in state warrants, grand jury indictments and financial crimes, and citywide felony charges in Central Bond Court. Judge Marubio is dedicated to her assignments and is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal experience, and fine temperament.

LIAM KELLY -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Liam Kelly declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

The Chicago Bar Association today released its evaluations of candidates for judicial positions in the upcoming primary. The CBA's process and criteria are explained in this post. The CBA's complete findings and explanations of those findings may be found by following this link.

The CBA says that 104 candidates are seeking Circuit Court positions. Of these, 91 were screened by the CBA. The 13 candidates who did not submit to screening were automatically found "Not Recommended" according to CBA JEC governing bylaws. Ten of the 91 who were screened were also found "Not Recommended."

On the other hand, the CBA Judicial Evaluation Committee found 13 Circuit Court candidates "Highly Qualified" and 68 other candidates "Qualified."

This post will look only at the CBA's ratings of candidates running in the 12th, 13th, 14th, and 15th Subcircuits.



Democratic Primary Candidates

PATRICIA M. FALLON -- QUALIFIED

Judge Patricia M. Fallon is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Fallon was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2001 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2019. Judge Fallon has practiced law in the private, corporate and government sectors. Judge Fallon is well regarded for her knowledge of the law, trial experience, and excellent temperament and demeanor.

HOWARD J. WISE -- QUALIFIED

Howard J. Wise is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Wise was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1997 and is currently in private practice concentrating in criminal law, traffic, DUI and personal injury matters. Mr. Wise is hardworking and well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, and fine temperament.

CARMINE TROMBETTA -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Carmine Trombetta declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

Republican Primary Candidate

FRANK R. DiFRANCO -- QUALIFIED

Frank R. DiFranco is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. DiFranco was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1987 and is currently a solo practitioner concentrating in criminal felony, misdemeanor, DUI, traffic, and personal injury matters. Mr. DiFranco has extensive experience in a wide range of civil and criminal matters and is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, and good demeanor.



Democratic Primary Candidates

JOE GUMP -- QUALIFIED

Joe Gump is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Gump was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1987 and for the past 29 years has served as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender. Mr. Gump is currently a felony assistant, assigned to the Third Municipal District. Mr. Gump is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability and fine temperament.

MATT FLAMM -- QUALIFIED

Matt Flamm is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Flamm was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1978 and is engaged in private practice concentrating in business and real estate litigation, real estate tax exemptions, tax sale, tax deed, and election law matters. Mr. Flamm is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, legal ability, and excellent demeanor.

MICHAEL HARRY MINTON -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Michael Harry Minton is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Minton was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1971 and has concentrated his practice in domestic relations and family law matters. Mr. Minton has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for his knowledge of family law. However, concerns about his punctuality and diligence resulted in a “Not Recommended” finding.

SUSANNE MICHELE GROEBNER -- QUALIFIED

Susanne Groebner is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Groebner was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2000 and is currently serving as a Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney in the Third Municipal District. Ms. Groebner has tried many complex cases and is well respected by judges and lawyers for her knowledge of the law, outstanding trial skills, fine demeanor and temperament.

MICHAEL P. GERBER -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Judge Michael P. Gerber is “Highly Qualified” for the office Circuit Court Judge. Judge Gerber was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1980 and served as a Cook County Assistant Public Defender for four years and as a Cook County Assistant State’s Attorney for 32 years before his appointment to the Circuit Court in 2016. Judge Gerber is highly regarded for his knowledge of the law, judicial ability, commitment to fairness, and excellent temperament.

Republican Primary Candidates

ANGEL GARCIA -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Angel Garcia declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.

GARY WILLIAM SEYRING -- QUALIFIED

Gary William Seyring is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Mr. Seyring was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1978 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in family law, real estate, business law, and wills, trusts and estates. Mr. Seyring has commercial litigation experience and is well regarded for his knowledge of probate, tax and family law. Mr. Seyring is actively involved in community service and highly regarded by the judges before whom he has appeared.



GERARDO TRISTAN, JR. -- QUALIFIED

Judge Gerardo Tristan is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Tristan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2002 and was appointed a Cook County Circuit Court Judge in 2019. Prior to his appointment to the bench, Judge Tristan served as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney, First Chair, in a Felony Courtroom. Judge Tristan has extensive trial experience and is well regarded for his knowledge of the law, fairness and fine temperament.

STEVE DEMITRO -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Steve Demitro declined to participate in the Judicial Evaluation Committee (JEC) screening process and, therefore, according to The Chicago Bar Association’s governing resolution for the JEC, is automatically found NOT RECOMMENDED.


DANIEL O. TIERNAN -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Judge Daniel O. Tiernan is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Tiernan was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1995 and served from 1995 to 2007 as an Assistant Cook County State’s Attorney. He was in private practice for nine years and since 2016 he has served as an investigator in Cook County’s Office of the Independent Inspector General. Mr. Tiernan is well regarded for his legal knowledge, legal ability, experience and integrity.

PERLA TIRADO -- NOT RECOMMENDED

Perla Tirado is “Not Recommended” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Tirado was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2005 and served as an Assistant Cook County Public Defender until 2007. Ms. Tirado was engaged in private practice from 2007-2016 and is currently serving as a Supervising Attorney for a not-for-profit legal aid provider. Ms. Tirado has a fine demeanor, but lacks the depth and breadth of practice experience to effectively serve as a Circuit Court Judge.



HEATHER MULLIGAN BEGLEY -- QUALIFIED

Heather Begley is “Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Ms. Begley was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 2003 and is currently engaged in private practice concentrating in personal injury and medical malpractice matters. Ms. Begley is hardworking and well regarded for her legal knowledge, legal ability, and excellent temperament.

NICHOLE C. PATTON -- HIGHLY QUALIFIED

Judge Nichole C. Patton is “Highly Qualified” for the office of Circuit Court Judge. Judge Patton was admitted to practice law in Illinois in 1997 and was appointed to the Circuit Court in 2018. Judge Patton is currently assigned to the County Division. Judge Patton has extensive knowledge and experience in mental health law and works well with pro se litigants. Judge Patton is dedicated to the justice system and is well respected by the lawyers and litigants who appear before her. Judge Patton is highly regarded for her knowledge of the law, legal ability, diligence, fine demeanor, and excellent temperament.

Personal PAC, the abortion rights lobbying group, has issued its list of endorsements for the forthcoming primary.

Five of the seven Supreme Court candidates received Personal PAC's endorsement. In listed order, Personal PAC endorses Daniel Epstein, Shelly Harris, Nathaniel Howse, Jesse Reyes, and Margaret Stanton McBride.

No candidate for the Simon vacancy on the Appellate Court received an endorsement from Personal PAC. In the race for the Neville, Jr. vacancy, Carolyn Gallagher and Sandra Ramos were endorsed.

In Circuit Court races, Personal PAC made the following endorsements:


Bellows Vacancy -- Kerrie Maloney Laytin
Coghlan Vacancy -- Elizabeth Ryan
Ford Vacancy -- Laura Ayala-Gonzalez
Funderburk Vacancy -- Celestia Mays
Larsen Vacancy -- Levander Smith, Jr.
Mason Vacancy -- Bonnie Carol McGrath
Mason Vacancy -- Chris Stacey
McCarthy Vacancy -- Teresa Molina
Murphy Gorman Vacancy -- Sheree Desiree Henry
O'Brien Vacancy -- Lloyd James Brooks
Patti Vacancy -- Lynn Weaver Boyle
Roti Vacancy -- James Patrick Crawley
Roti Vacancy -- Araceli Reyes De La Cruz
C. Sheehan Vacancy -- Deidre Baumann
C. Sheehan Vacancy -- Maura McMahon Zeller
K. Sheehan Vacancy -- Jill Rose Quinn


"A" Vacancy -- Sondra Nicole Denmark


Flynn Vacancy -- David Bonoma



Nega Vacancy -- Jamie Guerra Dickler
Nega Vacancy -- Anne Shaw
Pantle Vacancy -- Eileen Marie O'Connor


Fleming Vacancy -- Jonathan Clark Green
Fleming Vacancy -- Bradley Trowbridge


Axelrood Vacancy -- Pamela Stratigakis
Luckman Vacancy -- Michael Alan Strom


Allen Vacancy -- John Mulroe
McGing Vacancy -- Jon Stromsta
O'Brien Vacancy -- Audrey Victoria Cosgrove
O'Brien Vacancy -- Liam Kelly
O'Brien Vacancy -- Mary Catherine Marubio


Kulys Hoffman Vacancy -- Susanne Groebner
Kulys Hoffman Vacancy -- Joe Gump
Kulys Hoffman Vacancy -- Michael Minton


Griffin Vacancy -- Heather Mulligan Begley

The Independent Voters of Illinois - Independent Precinct Organization has made its endorsements for the upcoming primary.

In the race for the Illinois Supreme Court, the IVI-IPO has endorsed Justice P. Scott Neville, Jr.. The IVI-IPO also endorsed Justice Michael Hyman for the Neville vacancy on the Appellate Court and Judge Sharon Johnson for the Simon vacancy.

In Cook County Circuit Court races, the IVI-IPO made the following endorsements:


Bellows Vacancy -- Cristin K. McDonald Duffy
Coghlan Vacancy -- Aileen Bhandari
Larsen Vacancy -- Megan Kathleen Mulay
Mason Vacancy -- Joseph Chico
McCarthy Vacancy -- Michael O'Malley
Murphy Gorman Vacancy -- Sheree Desiree Henry
O'Brien Vacancy -- Lloyd James Brooks
Roti Vacancy -- James Patrick Crawley
C. Sheehan Vacancy -- Deidre Baumann
K. Sheehan Vacancy -- James Samuel Worley


"A" Vacancy -- Chelsey Robinson


Jackson Vacancy -- Owens "Joe" Shelby


Fleming Vacancy -- Bradley Trowbridge


Luckman Vacancy -- Michael Alan Strom


McGing Vacancy -- Maire Aileen Dempsey


Kulys Hoffman Vacancy -- Joe Gump

The Fraternal Order of Police, Chicago Lodge No. 7, has announced its endorsements in Cook County judicial races for the upcoming primary.

The FOP made no endorsements for either First District Appellate Court vacancy. However, the Lodge did endorse Justice Jesse Reyes for the Illinois Supreme Court.

In Circuit Court races, the FOP made the following endorsements:


Bellows Vacancy -- Cristin McDonald Duffy
Coghlan Vacancy -- Elizabeth "Beth" Ryan (Well Qualified)
Coghlan Vacancy -- Aileen Bhandari (Well Qualified)
Ford Vacancy -- Laura Ayala-Gonzalez
Funderburk Vacancy -- Jacqueline Marie Griffin
Larsen Vacancy -- Megan Kathleen Mulay
Mason Vacancy -- Joy E. Tolbert Nelson
McCarthy Vacancy -- Michael O'Malley
Murphy Gorman Vacancy -- Amanda "Mandy" Pillsbury
O'Brien Vacancy -- Heather Anne Kent
Roti Vacancy -- Lorraine Mary Murphy
C. Sheehan Vacancy -- Russell Hartigan
K. Sheehan Vacancy -- James Samuel Worley


Flynn Vacancy -- Lauren Brougham Glennon
Murphy Vacancy -- Erin Haggerty Antonietti


Jackson Vacancy -- Kristen Marie Lyons


Axelrood Vacancy -- Pamela Stratigakis


Allen Vacancy -- John Mulroe
McGing Vacancy -- John Garrido
O'Brien Vacancy -- Daniel Trevino


Hanlon Vacancy -- Patricia Fallon


Lacy Vacancy -- Daniel Tiernan

If Clint Krislov had been able to survive to the ballot in his bid for the Illinois Supreme Court, he would also have received a "Well Qualified" from the FOP.

The FOP endorsed Bob Fioretti in the Democratic Primary for State's Attorney and my undergraduate and law school classmate, Chris Pfannkuche in the Republican Primary.

In another race of interest to FWIW readers, the FOP endorsed Richard Boykin for Circuit Court Clerk.

The Chicago Council of Lawyers has now released its evaluations of Cook County judicial candidates. The CCL's complete report, including its full explanation of the criteria it uses in evaluating judicial candidates, can be accessed from this page on the CCL website.

But, to summarize, the Council works with the other members of the Alliance of Bar Associations for Judicial Screening (namely, the Arab American Bar Association, the Asian American Bar Association, the Black Women Lawyers Association, the Cook County Bar Association, the Decalogue Society of Lawyers, the Hellenic Bar Association, the Hispanic Lawyers’ Association of Illinois, the Illinois State Bar Association, the Lesbian and Gay Bar Association of Chicago, the Puerto Rican Bar Association, and the Women’s Bar Association of Illinois) in investigating candidates.

Candidates seeking screening from the Alliance must complete a lengthy questionnaire (a questionnaire that is similar to, but sufficiently different from, the separate Chicago Bar Association questionnaire that completion of one will not suffice for the other). Investigators will be assigned by the Alliance from any of the member groups; thus, Council members are not necessarily involved in the vetting of any candidate's written application (calling references, reviewing written submissions, and so forth). When that phase of the investigation is completed, and after medical waivers and ARDC (or JIB) waivers are obtained, a hearing is scheduled for the applicant. All Alliance groups are asked to participate in these hearings. Each evaluator at the hearings will have the benefit of the Alliance investigators' work, even though the investigators may not be associated with the evaluator's bar group.

Each Alliance member evaluates a candidate according to its own criteria. The criteria for the Council’s evaluations are whether the candidate has demonstrated the ability to serve on the relevant court in the following categories:

• fairness, including sensitivity to diversity and bias
• legal knowledge and skills (competence)
• integrity
• experience
• diligence
• impartiality
• judicial temperament
• respect for the rule of law
• independence from political and institutional influences
• professional conduct
• character
• community service

The Council rates candidates as “highly qualified,” “well qualified,” “qualified,” or “not qualified.” If a candidate refuses to submit his or her credentials to the Council, that candidate is rated “not recommended” unless the Council is aware of credible information that would justify a “not qualified” rating. Because the Council believes that a willingness to participate in bar association and other public evaluations is a key indicator of fitness for public office, no candidate who refuses to be screened can be found “qualified.”

If a candidate has demonstrated the ability to perform the work required of a judge in all of these areas, the Council assigns a rating of “qualified.” If a candidate has demonstrated excellence in most of these areas, the Council assigns a rating of “well qualified.” If a candidate has demonstrated excellence in all of these areas, the Council assigns a rating of “highly qualified.” If a candidate has not demonstrated that he or she meets all of the criteria evaluated by the Council, the Council assigns a rating of “not qualified.”

The Council holds Supreme Court and Appellate Court candidates to higher standards than candidates for the Circuit Court. The Council does not evaluate candidates based on their substantive views of political or social issues. Nor does the Council take into account the particular race in which a candidate is running or the candidates against whom a candidate is running.

When a candidate is a sitting judge, the Council places special importance on interviews with attorneys who practice before the judge, particularly those who were not referred to the Council by the candidate. Most evaluations are based on information gathered and interviews held during the past few months. In cases where the Alliance evaluated candidates within the past five years, the Alliance requested updated information, but did not investigate or interview candidates again for the March 2020 primary, instead relying on the earlier results.

The Council takes the position that a very good lawyer may not be a judge. Accordingly, the Council cautions that, "it should be recognized and expected that we will rate some good lawyers 'not qualified.'"

With these preliminaries in mind, we begin reviewing the Council's evaluations of Cook County judicial candidates running in the March primary. This post will focus solely on the Council's review of candidates for the Supreme Court. In future posts we will cover the Council's evaluations of candidates for the Appellate Court and the various countywide and subcircuit Circuit Court vacancies.

Hon. Jesse G. Reyes -- Qualified

Hon. Jesse G. Reyes was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 1984. Since 2012, he has served as a Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court, First District, Fourth Division. Previously he was a Cook County Circuit Judge, where his assignments included the Chancery Division’s Mortgage Foreclosure/Mechanics Lien Section (2005-2012); the Chancery Division, County Department and the First Municipal District, Municipal Department (2002-2005); the First Municipal District, First District (2001-2005, 1997-1999); and the Sixth Municipal District (Markham; 1999-2001).

Judge Reyes has good legal ability and has had substantial experience both as a trial judge and as an Appellate Court Justice. He is reported to be well prepared at oral argument and his opinions are reported to be well written and well-reasoned. The Council finds him Qualified for the Illinois Supreme Court.

Hon. P. Scott Neville, Jr. – Well Qualified

Hon. P. Scott Neville, Jr. was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 1974. In 2018, he was appointed to serve as a Justice on the Illinois Supreme Court. He has also acted as a liaison to the IPI Civil Instructions Committee, the Illinois Rules of Evidence Committee, and the Pretrial Practices Committee. Previously, he served as Judge of the Appellate Court of Illinois (2004-2018) and as a Judge on the Cook County Circuit Court (1999-2004).

Justice Neville has been praised for his legal ability and for his diligence throughout his judicial career. His questioning during oral argument reflect his thorough preparation and understanding of the issues. He is generally praised for his integrity. Justice Neville has been involved in community activities and reform-minded efforts throughout his career. He is considered to be an excellent jurist with an understanding that judges can be active supporters of reforms aimed at improving the effectiveness and fairness of our courts. He actively works for improving the fairness and effectiveness of Illinois courts, and he is praised by social justice advocates for positions he has taken as a Supreme Court Justice. The Council finds him Well Qualified for the Illinois Supreme Court.

Hon. Sheldon A. Harris -- Qualified

Hon. Sheldon A. Harris was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 1966. Since 2010, he has served as a Justice of the Appellate Court of Illinois, First District. Prior to that, he served as a Cook County Circuit Court Judge, where he was assigned to the Law Division, Trial Section (2008-2010), the First Municipal District (2005-2008), Mediation and Arbitration (2002-2005), the Chancery Division, as the designated pro bono mentor to attorneys representing litigants in the Circuit Court of Cook County under the CSA Access to Justice Pro Bono Project (2001-2002), and the Municipal and Divorce Division Supplemental and Miscellaneous Remedies (2000-2001), Prior to becoming a judge, he worked at his own law firm, Sheldon A. Harris and Associates (1974-2000), where he specialized in tort jury and non-jury litigation, and as Staff Attorney at the Legal Aid Bureau of Chicago (1966-1970).

Judge Harris is considered to be knowledgeable and hard-working. Those with experience in the Appellate Court say that he is attentive during oral arguments and that is opinions are well-reasoned and well-written. The Council finds him Qualified for the Supreme Court.

Hon. Cynthia Y. Cobbs -- Qualified

Hon. Cynthia Y. Cobbs was admitted to practice in 1988. In 2014, she was appointed to the First District Appellate Court, and she remains in that position. Originally, appointed as a Circuit Court Judge in 2011 and then elected in 2014, , her previous judicial duties included Forcible Entry and Detainer (2012-2015), Civil Jury Trials (2014), Pro Se Court (2012-2013), Small Claims/Debt Collector/Breach of Contract (2012), and Traffic Court (2011). Prior to becoming a judge, she served in a variety of positions at the Supreme Court of Illinois’s Administrative Office of the Illinois Courts, including Director of (2002-2011), Chief Legal Counsel (1999-2002), and Secretary to the Supreme Court Rules Committee (1997-1999). She is a member of a number of bar associations, including the Illinois State Bar Association, the Black Women Lawyer Association, and the Illinois Judicial Council, where she has served as Chair (2018-2019).

Judge Cobbs lacked litigation experience when she took the trial court bench, but has since established herself as both a solid trial court jurist and as an appellate court judge. She is praised for her legal ability and for always being prepared. She is reported to have good temperament. She is also praised for the quality of her written decisions. The Council finds her Qualified for the Illinois Supreme Court.

Hon. Margaret Stanton McBride – Well Qualified

Hon. Margaret Stanton McBride was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 1976. Since 1998, she has served as a Justice of the Illinois Appellate Court, First District, where since 2018 she has been Presiding Judge of the Fourth Division. Prior to that, she served as a Cook County Circuit Court Judge, where her assignments included Presiding Judge, Third Municipal District (1997-1998); Chancery Division, Calendar 2 (1994-1997); Law Division, Jury Call (1992-1994); Criminal Division (1990-1992); and Traffic Court, Misdemeanor Branch Courts, and Felony Preliminary Hearing Courts, First Municipal District (1987-1990). Before becoming a judge, she served as an Assistant State’s Attorney in the Cook County State’s Attorney Office (for 10 years) and as an Associate at Egan & Keane, a general practice civil firm (for 9 months). Currently she serves as Elected Appellate Court Member of the Illinois Courts Commission (2007-present); a Member of the Illinois Supreme Court Judicial Performance Evaluation Committee (2011-present); Appointed Member of the Illinois Supreme Court Rules Committee (2012-present); and a Member of the Appellate Committee of the Illinois Supreme Court Access to Justice Commission (2015-present).

Justice McBride is considered to have excellent legal ability She is reported to be well prepared for each case and to have an outstanding grasp of the law and facts. She is praised for the quality of her written opinions. She is reported to be exceptionally hard-working. Respondents say she has very good temperament – polite but firm, She is highly respected for her work with Supreme Court reform-minded committees. She has an excellent reputation for leading initiatives that lead to meaningful reforms and she is highly praised for her integrity. The Council finds her Well Qualified for the Illinois Supreme Court.

Daniel A. Epstein – Not Recommended

Daniel A. Epstein was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 2015. Since April 2019, he has been running full-time as a candidate for the Illinois Supreme Court. Prior to that, he served as an Associate at Jenner & Block, where he worked as a litigator on appellate and post-conviction, criminal, insurance, government contracts, and commercial and business torts matters.

Alliance for Judicial Screening rules say that all candidates with fewer than 5 years of experience must be found Not Recommended. However, in light of the importance of Supreme Court Justice position, the Council also says the following:

Daniel Epstein is a respected lawyer dedicated to advancing the rule of law, but who has very little litigation experience. Law is a second career for him.
Mr. Epstein demonstrates maturity and the ability to formulate and advocate for ideas for reform of the justice system. He has published, law-related works. More than one respondent said that they would consider him Qualified for a trial judge seat, despite his lack of litigation experience because of his dedication to use the position of Illinois Supreme Court Justice to move forward an agenda of reforms seeking to make the lower courts more fair, effective, and efficient.

The Council recognizes that only part of the Illinois Supreme Court’s role is to improve access to and quality of the court system. Its role in deciding cases that include complex legal issues that affect state-wide policy as well as individual rights requires its Justices to have litigation experience in a variety of areas. While Mr. Epstein is to be admired for running a reform-minded campaign, he does not have that litigation experience. The Council finds him Not Qualified for the Illinois Supreme Court.

Hon. Nathaniel R. Howse, Jr. – Well Qualified

Hon. Nathaniel R. Howse, Jr. was admitted to the Illinois Bar in 1976. Since 2009, he has served as a Justice of the Appellate Court of Illinois, First District. Prior to that, he served as a Cook County Circuit Court Judge, where he was assigned to the County Division (2001-2009), where he presided over Tax Deed, Real Estate Tax, Civil Forfeiture, and Adoption cases; and the First Municipal District, where he heard supplemental proceedings to enforce judgments as well as extraordinary remedies (2000-2001); served as floater judge on general assignment (1999-2000); and presided over traffic cases (1998-1999).

Judge Howse is considered to have excellent legal ability and is reported to demonstrate a good grasp of complex issues. His written opinions are praised as being well-written, well-reasoned, and thorough. Respondents say he is always well prepared for oral argument. His integrity is highly respected and his temperament is reported to be even-tempered. The Council finds him Well Qualified for the Illinois Supreme Court.